This SCOTUS case will determine the Social Security benefits of tens of thousands of National Guard members

By Published On: October 12, 2021Last Updated: May 24, 20241.2 min read

On the morning of Wednesday, October 13, you can tune in to listen to live oral arguments in the case of Babcock v. Kijakazi. There will also be transcripts and an audio recording released soon after.

This case addresses the question of whether certain civilian employees of the National Guard, known as “military technician (dual status)” should have their pensions for this work considered “a payment based wholly on service as a member of a uniformed service” for the purposes of the Social Security Act’s windfall elimination provision, or WEP. This question affects the potential Social Security benefits of tens of thousands of National Guard members.

The Eighth Circuit decided that pensions of dual status military technicians are wholly based on service as a member of a uniformed service and the Windfall Elimination Provision should not apply. That allows technicians who live in Arkansas, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, and South Dakota, to have higher Social Security benefits. But the Ninth, Tenth, Eleventh, and Sixth (Babcock’s home) circuits have all either said that the law dictates that the WEP should apply, or that the law is unclear but the Social Security Administration’s position of applying the WEP is reasonable.

It may take several months for the Supreme Court to issue a decision in the Babcock case. Commentary and an easy-to-navigate list of documents from the case are available on the SCOTUSblog website.

Share!

Follow us
Recent posts

New leadership is a reason for optimism in 2024

On December 20, 2023, Martin J. O’Malley was sworn in as Commissioner of Social Security. He will serve until January 19, 2025. After more than two years of leadership uncertainty and instability at SSA, O’Malley’s...

Spotlight on SSA’s budget: NYT and 60 Minutes

The budget crisis at SSA continues to hurt the most vulnerable among us, with administrative delays, redundancies, and overpayment clawbacks that put the onus on beneficiaries to correct the agency’s errors. Public pressure is building...

Electronic Signature EM Extended

Please note that SSA Emergency Message (EM) 20022 has been extended until June 13, 2024. This EM provides guidance on how the agency must process electronic signatures on certain forms. You can view the complete...