
Piemonte’s Perspective
February 25, 2026
George Piemonte, NOSSCR Past President
Reexamining “Marker” Jobs: When the Numbers, and the Occupation Itself, No Longer Add Up
In disability adjudication, few moments carry as much weight as VE testimony at step five. Job numbers offered by a VE often determine the outcome of a case, yet those numbers are frequently accepted without meaningful inquiry into their methodological foundations or real-world accuracy. The occupation of “Marker” (DOT 209.587-034) is cited many, many times for a “light” RFC finding. But this occupation illustrates two fundamental problems that increasingly undermine VE testimony: unreliable numerical methodology and reliance on an outdated job description that no longer reflects how work is performed in the modern economy.
The Hypothetical and the VE’s Conclusion
The following example illustrates the problem of failing to cross-examine on job numbers. The ALJ poses a hypothetical individual limited to light work with additional postural and environmental restrictions: lifting up to 20 pounds occasionally and 10 pounds frequently; standing and walking for six hours; sitting for six hours; no climbing of ladders, ropes, or scaffolds; only occasional stooping, crouching, kneeling, or crawling; and only occasional exposure to moving machinery and unprotected heights. The VE testified that such an individual could perform the job of Marker and asserted that approximately 140,000 such jobs exist nationally.
That testimony appears straightforward until it is examined.
Premise One: The Numbers Are Not Reliable
The VE gives a word salad explanation of their methodology, or they just used the DOL, BLS, OEWS, ect, etc. When pressed to explain how the 140,000-job figure was calculated, the VE concedes that the methodology had not been published or peer reviewed. By contrast, the Department of Labor’s Occupational Requirements Survey (ORS) was created at the request of the Social Security Administration specifically for disability adjudication. SSR 24-3p expressly recognizes the ORS as an acceptable and reliable source of occupational data.
The Marker occupation exists only as a DOT title; in modern labor statistics, it is subsumed under Standard Occupational Classification (SOC) 53-7065, “Stockers and Order Fillers.” According to the OEWS, this SOC contains approximately 2.87 million workers nationwide. Using ORS data, however, the job pool erodes rapidly when legitimate vocational factors are applied:
- Only 40.4% of Stockers and Order Fillers are full-time.
- Of those, 85.5% are unskilled.
- At the 10th percentile, workers in this SOC stand for 80% of the workday.
- Only at the 10th percentile do lifting requirements fall below 25 pounds.
Let’s Do The Math
Below is the arithmetic that corresponds to the erosion described in the bullet points immediately above, using the 2.87 million SOC base and applying the explicit proportions/percentiles stated in the article.
Start (SOC base):
- Total workers in SOC 53-7065: 2,870,000
Step 1 — Full-time filter (40.4%):
2,870,000 × 0.404 = 1,159,480
Step 2 — Unskilled filter (85.5% of the remaining pool):
1,159,480 × 0.855 = 991,355
Step 3 — Standing requirement tied to the 10th percentile:
At the 10th percentile for standing (stand 80% of the day at the 10th percentile).
Treating that as “only the bottom 10% of jobs meet (or are at/below) that threshold,” the qualifying share is 0.10.
991,355 × 0.10 = 99,135
Step 4 — Lifting requirement tied to the 10th percentile:
Lifting falls below 25 pounds only at the 10th percentile, so only another 0.10 share meets that requirement.
99,135 × 0.10 = 9,913
Result after the stated factors:
- Approximately 9,914 jobs, when applying the RFC limitations.
Context against the VE’s asserted 140,000:
140,000 ÷ 9,914 ≈ 14.12×
140,000 − 9,914 = 130,086
So the VE’s 140,000 figure is about 14 times the pre-postural/pre-environmental pool produced by the stated ORS/SOC erosion steps, before additional RFC restrictions are even applied.
Applying these factors reduces the potential job pool from nearly 2.9 million to fewer than 10,000 jobs, before even accounting for postural, climbing, or environmental limitations. Additional erosion using O*NET and ORS data reduces the number further, to approximately 6,000 jobs nationally. If the RFC limits interaction to only occasional contact with others, the number drops to roughly 240.
Against this backdrop, the VE’s testimony of 140,000 Marker jobs is not merely optimistic; it is mathematically indefensible.
Premise Two: The DOT “Marker” No Longer Exists as Described
Even if one were to set aside the numerical flaws, a deeper problem remains: the DOT description of Marker itself is obsolete.
The DOT portrays Marker as a worker who manually marks prices on items using tickets, tags, or labels. That description reflects a retail environment that largely ceased to exist decades ago. In the modern economy, pricing, inventory control, and product identification are dominated by the Universal Product Code (UPC) and integrated digital inventory systems. Prices are embedded in centralized computer databases and linked to barcodes that are scanned at the point of sale. Price changes are implemented electronically, not by hand-labeling individual items.
As a result, the core tasks described in DOT 209.587-034, manual price marking with minimal judgment, have largely disappeared. Where labeling work still occurs, it is typically performed using handheld scanners, inventory software, and storewide pricing systems that require interaction with computerized databases. These tasks bear little resemblance to the rote, manual labor contemplated by the DOT and raise serious questions about whether the occupation remains “unskilled” under SSA’s regulatory framework.
Unskilled work is defined as requiring little or no judgment and a short demonstration to learn. Operating scanning devices, navigating inventory systems, reconciling electronic price changes, and coordinating with centralized pricing controls arguably exceed that threshold. Yet VEs routinely continue to classify Marker as SVP 2 without addressing this technological transformation.
The Combined Impact: Fewer Jobs, Higher Skill
When these two premises are considered together, the weakness of Marker testimony becomes apparent. First, reliable, SSA-endorsed data sources reduce the number of viable jobs to a fraction of what VEs often claim. Second, the occupation itself, at least as described in the DOT, has been functionally overtaken by technology, calling into question whether it remains unskilled or even exists in meaningful numbers at all.
Courts have long recognized the DOT’s age, but hearings frequently proceed as though nothing has changed since the 1970s. The prevalence of UPC systems is not a niche development; it is a defining feature of modern retail and logistics. Treating Marker as a static, timeless occupation ignores economic reality.
Significant Numbers and Judicial Review
Whether 6,000 or 240 jobs constitute a “significant number” remains a circuit-specific inquiry. But the threshold question should come first: are these jobs accurately counted and accurately described?
When VE testimony relies on unpublished methods and outdated occupational descriptions, it fails that test.
Conclusion
The Marker occupation presents a dual vulnerability that practitioners can no longer afford to ignore. The numbers do not withstand scrutiny when tested against the ORS, and the job itself no longer resembles the unskilled, manual task described in the DOT. Effective cross-examination must therefore do more than challenge job incidence figures; it must also confront the assumption that Marker still exists in the national economy as described.
This two-pronged approach, attacking both the math and the mismatch between the DOT and modern work, creates a stronger record, sharper judicial issues, and a more accurate step-five analysis. While Marker may remain a stubborn fixture in disability hearings, its foundations are increasingly difficult to defend.
The views and opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of NOSSCR, its leadership, or staff.

