
Piemonte’s Perspective
March 26, 2026
George Piemonte, NOSSCR Past President
Last month, I discussed two foundational premises for challenging the Marker job. The second premise was that the job, as described, no longer exists in the modern economy as set forth in the DOT. This month, I turn to practical ways to cross-examine the vocational expert on that point.
A brief disclaimer at the outset: what follows is not an exhaustive list. You will not necessarily need to use every question, and you should expect to adapt, add to, or modify them based on the VE’s testimony. These questions are intended as a guide, tools to help you shape a focused and effective cross-examination, not a script to be followed verbatim.
I. Foundational Questions (Lock the VE Into Their Sources and Methodology)
These questions establish what the VE actually relied upon, which SSR 24‑3p now makes critical.
- Before offering your testimony today, what specific occupational information sources did you rely upon to identify the job of Marker, DOT 209.587‑034?
- Did you rely on the DOT description itself as written, without modification?
- Did you consult any post‑DOT sources, such as O*NET, employer surveys, labor market software, or job analyses, to evaluate whether the DOT description reflects how this work is currently performed?
- Can you identify, with specificity, which source you relied on to determine that the Marker occupation still exists in significant numbers in today’s economy as an unskilled job?
- What steps, if any, did you take to evaluate whether technological changes have altered the core tasks of this occupation since the DOT was last updated?
Purpose:
SSR 24-3p requires transparency regarding sources and reasoning. If the VE relied solely on the DOT or cannot articulate a modern source, the record is already compromised.
II. Obsolescence and Technological Change (Attack the DOT Description Itself)
These questions expose the disconnect between the DOT’s manual‑labeling description and the modern retail economy.
- The DOT describes Marker as manually marking prices using tickets, tags, or labels. Are you aware that most retail pricing today is controlled electronically through UPC barcodes and centralized databases?
- In your professional experience, do modern retail establishments generally change prices by manually tagging each item, or through electronic price updates linked to barcode systems?
- Can you identify industries today where manual price marking, as described in the DOT, is the primary method of pricing goods?
- Would you agree that the DOT description of Marker does not mention barcode scanners, inventory software, or electronic pricing systems?
- If those technologies are now integral to the job, would that mean the DOT description does not fully describe how the job is performed today?
Purpose:
You are establishing factual obsolescence, not merely “conflict,” which SSR 24‑3p recognizes as a legitimate reliability issue.
III. Skill Level and SVP Assumptions (Challenge the “Unskilled” Classification)
These questions target the SVP 2 classification, a frequent weak point.
- Unskilled work is defined as requiring little or no judgment and a short demonstration to learn, correct?
- Does operating handheld scanners, navigating inventory systems, or reconciling electronic price changes require interaction with computerized systems?
- Would those tasks require workers to understand menus, prompts, or system feedback?
- Do those requirements involve judgment beyond simple, repetitive manual tasks?
- Did you perform any analysis to determine whether these modern tasks are consistent with unskilled work as defined in the regulations?
- Is your classification of Marker as SVP 2 based on the DOT alone, rather than on how the job is actually performed today?
Purpose:
This lays the groundwork for arguing that even if the job exists, it is misclassified, making the RFC/job match legally defective.
IV. Methodology for Job Numbers (Expose Speculation and Aggregation)
SSR 24-3p places greater emphasis on reasoned explanation, especially for job-number testimony.
- What is your methodology for estimating the number of Marker jobs in the national economy?
- Do your job‑numbers estimate distinguish between manual price marking and electronically assisted inventory or pricing work?
- Are the numbers you provided derived from a broader occupational group rather than this specific DOT title?
- If so, what steps did you take to ensure that the numbers you cited correspond only to work matching the DOT description?
- Can you identify any data source that separately tracks manual price‑marking jobs as described in DOT 209.587‑034?
Purpose:
You are setting up a numbers-reliability challenge, which courts increasingly scrutinize post-SSR 24-3p.
V. SSR 24‑3p Compliance (Force the VE to Admit Gaps)
These questions explicitly frame the issue for judicial review.
- Under current SSA policy, vocational testimony must be supported by a reasoned explanation tied to reliable occupational information sources, correct?
- Can you explain how your testimony accounts for the technological changes that have occurred since the DOT was last updated?
- Did you provide the ALJ with any explanation reconciling the DOT’s manual‑labeling description with modern, computerized pricing systems?
- If no such explanation was provided, would you agree that the record contains no analysis of whether this occupation still matches the DOT description?
Purpose:
This squarely tees up a legal insufficiency argument under current policy.
VI. Preservation Questions (For District Court Review)
These questions are designed purely to lock in reversible error.
- As you sit here today, can you point to any written vocational source confirming that the Marker occupation, as described in the DOT, still exists in its original form?
- Is it fair to say your testimony assumes, rather than demonstrates, that the DOT description remains accurate?
- If the DOT description no longer reflects how the work is performed, would your testimony necessarily be unreliable?
Purpose:
These questions preserve arguments that the ALJ relied on unsupported vocational testimony, a classic basis for remand.
The views and opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of NOSSCR, its leadership, or staff.

