The Social Security Forum

Powley v. Bisignano: Huge 9th Circuit Win Revitalizes Efficacy of VE Rebuttal Evidence

March 26, 2026

Sara Rose Carroll, NOSSCR Member and Conference Presenter

Background

Kevin Kerr, a NOSSCR board member and a managing partner at Kerr Robichaux & Carroll, submitted 91 pages of vocational expert (VE) rebuttal evidence to the ALJ immediately after the hearing. The rebuttal evidence included print outs from the then most recent versions of Skilltran’s Job Browser Pro (JBP) and data from U.S. Census Bureau County Business Patterns. The sources reported job numbers and data directly in conflict with those provided by the VE at hearing. Alyson Young, a partner at Kerr Robichaux & Carroll, did the oral arguments in the 9th Circuit.

The VE testified that he relied solely on JBP for the job numbers he provided for jewelry preparer (700.687-062) and fishing reel assembler (732.684-062). Both occupations are in OES group 51-9199, which contains 1,527 DOT codes. JBP estimated that 0% of the OES group works as a jewelry preparer, and .8% (19) work as a fishing reel assembler. The VE testified that there were 24,700 jobs for the occupation of jewelry preparer and 14,700 jobs for the occupation of fishing reel assembler.

The VE testified that he used both JBP and consulted a “manufacturer” database for final assembler, optical goods (713.687-018). He said the database showed the number of jobs in various industries. However, he also acknowledged on cross examination that assembler, optical goods would be just one of many occupations making up the specific industry.  He testified that there are 39,425 people working as a final assembler, optical goods. The 2014 U.S. Census Bureau’s County Business Pattern data that Mr. Kerr submitted showed there were only 24,910 jobs in the entire Ophthalmic goods manufacturing industry (NAICS code 33915). JBP estimated there were 27 jobs for the DOT title final assembler, optical goods.

The court ultimately found that there was an unresolved direct conflict between the VE’s testimony and the rebuttal evidence that Mr. Kerr submitted.

The court distinguishes Powley from prior 9th Circuit cases like Kilpatrick v. Kijakazi, 35 F.4th 1187 (9th Cir. 2022) and Wischmann v. Kijakazi, 68 F.4th 498 (9th Cir. 2023). In Kilpatrick, the court held that the attorney had not identified their expertise in calculating the figures he submitted as a part of his rebuttal and that the attorney had conceded that his figures may not be “completely accurate.”  In Wischmann, the court held that the six pages of printouts submitted by the attorney were not probative because there was no explanation of how the job numbers were produced other than the software name and the attorney did not indicate whether they used the same methodology as the VE. Also, the vocational rebuttal evidence in Wischmann was not submitted to the ALJ before the decision was issued and was only submitted to the Appeals Council.

It is also important to note that the court does more than to distinguish Powley from Kilpatrick and Wischmann. Most notably, the court goes further and holds that we do not have to be “experts” and that we do not have to use the exact same methodology and sources as the VE, as long as the vocational rebuttal evidence is “significant and probative.”

Decision Summary

  • Whether or not we as attorneys are “experts” is only one factor to be considered when evaluating whether the rebuttal evidence we present is probative.
  • ALJ’s cannot only “address” that there is a discrepancy, they also must “resolve” the discrepancy if it is significant and probative.
  • VE testimony about relying on their “experience” to come up with job numbers is not in of itself sufficient to explain a direct conflict between the VE’s job numbers and probative evidence we submit.
  • We must make sure we clearly explain who “created the data” used in our rebuttal evidence (usually the hearings attorney), how they did so, and make sure that anyone looking at the rebuttal evidence can clearly tell the source the information came from (in this case Skilltran JBP and the US Census Bureau).
    • The court notes that the JBP printouts contained the name of the position and corresponding DOT, that those matched the DOT title testified to by the VE, and that Mr. Kerr included JBP’s methodology for generating job numbers and their data sources.
    • The court also notes that the census data provided details on the geography covered, the industry it concerns, and other information about the data therein.
  • We are not required to mirror the VE’s methods and sources for generating job numbers. It was sufficient that the attorney used sources like Skilltran and census data from the U.S. Census. The court notes that Skilltran JBP and US Census data are two sources frequently relied upon by the Agency. 

Insights

We urge representatives to get some kind of VE rebuttal evidence into the file immediately after the hearing. Making argument and crossing VEs during the hearing is likely not going to be sufficient to set your client up for appeal if it appears that is the way things are heading.

The court seems to be most comfortable with evidence that is generated by sources routinely relied upon the Agency and that is clearly in conflict with the Agency’s vocational expert testimony.

In discussing Kilpatrick, the court further explains their finding that the evidence submitted by the attorney in that case was not probative. “For instance, Kilpatrick’s attorney conceded that his figures ‘may not be completely accurate’ and that he had used a seemingly self-created equation to calculate his job numbers with no evidence that the SSA frequently relied on such a method.”

Thus, you may want to consider hiring a vocational expert if you intend to submit VE rebuttal that requires mathematical computations beyond what sources like JBP directly generate.  Fortunately in this case,  and hopefully in others in the future, using evidence generated by JBP appears to be enough.  


The views and opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of NOSSCR, its leadership, or staff.