The Social Security Forum

SSA’s FY 2025 Waterfall Data: What the Numbers Tell Us

April 30, 2026

Thomas A. Krause, NOSSCR Lifetime Member

Social Security Administration has released its Fiscal Year 2025 disability decision data, offering a comprehensive look at outcomes across every level of the appeals process. Here is what practitioners should know.

  1. Federal Court: Record Remand Rising, Shrinking Docket

The headline number from FY 2025 is the federal court remand rate, which reached 65%, the highest in at least the past 20 years of available data. To put that in perspective, the remand rate was 44% in FY 2006, climbed steadily through the teens, and has accelerated sharply in recent years: 59% in FY 2021, 58% in FY 2022, 61% in FY 2023, and 63% in FY 2024, before hitting this new high. For claimants who reach federal court, the odds of a remand back to SSA for further proceedings have never been better.

At the same time, the federal court docket is shrinking. SSA issued only 13,587 federal court decisions in FY 2025, down from 15,753 in FY 2024 and well below the recent peak of 21,297 in FY 2022. The allow rate at the federal court level has effectively collapsed to just 1%, where it has sat since FY 2021, meaning that when courts act favorably, they are almost always reversing and remanding for further proceedings rather than reversing and ordering an award of benefits.

  1. Appeals Council: A Surge in Decisions, Stable Remand Rate

One of the most striking changes in volume in FY 2025 involves the Appeals Council. SSA decided 83,759 requests for review, nearly double the 45,641 decided in FY 2024, and the highest figure since FY 2020’s 126,731. The FY 2024 number appeared anomalously low, and FY 2025 represents a substantial rebound in AC throughput that practitioners should factor into their timeline projections.

The remand rate at the Appeals Council held at 15% in FY 2025, consistent with the range of 11–16% seen from FY 2020 through FY 2024. It is worth noting, however, that this is a notably lower rate than the 18–25% remand rates the AC produced from FY 2006 through FY 2012. Whether that long-run decline reflects changes in Appeals Council review standards, ALJ decision quality, or something else is an open question, but the era of Appeals Council remands approaching one-in-four decisions appears to be behind us. The rate for denial of review held at 80% in FY 2025, and both the allow rate (1%) and dismiss rate (3%) remain negligible.

  1. ALJ Level: Stability After a Long Decline

The ALJ allowance rate in FY 2025 was 50%, within the 45–51% range that has prevailed since FY 2013. This represents a substantial and sustained decrease from the allowance rates of over 60% that characterized FY 2006 and FY 2009. The ALJ docket itself remains well below its historical highs: 277,740 decisions in FY 2025, compared to a peak of over 668,000 in FY 2012 at the height of the post-recession surge. The dismiss rate held at 16% and the deny rate at 33%.

For attorneys advising clients about their odds at hearing, the current environment is markedly more difficult than it was fifteen years ago, and there is no recent trend suggesting a return to the higher allowance rates of that era.

  1. Reconsideration and Initial Levels: Remarkable Consistency

The reconsideration and initial levels tell a story of long-run stability. The reconsideration allowance rate has ranged only from 11% to 16% over the entire 20-year period captured in this data, landing at 16% in FY 2025, matching FY 2024 and representing the high end of the historical range. Volume at reconsideration rose meaningfully, to 584,625 decisions in FY 2025 from 495,700 in FY 2024, which may partly explain the increased Appeals Council volume downstream.

At the initial level, the allowance rate was 36% in FY 2025, within the 33–39% band that has held since FY 2006. Initial decisions numbered 2,246,542 in FY 2025, up from 2,086,885 in FY 2024 and continuing a recovery from the trough of 1,765,032 in FY 2022.

  1. Takeaways for Practitioners

The FY 2025 data reinforce several durable realities about the disability appeals landscape: the most favorable outcomes are concentrated at the ALJ hearing level and, if cases advance that far, in federal court. The record 65% federal court remand rate is genuinely significant.  It reflects a judiciary that continues to find ALJ decisions legally deficient at a high rate. We should not be afraid to appeal cases that have been denied at hearing. The Appeals Council’s increased output is a welcome operational development, even if the remand rate there remains modest.

The overarching picture is one of a system where allowance rates are low and relatively flat at every pre-hearing stage, where the hearing level remains the pivotal forum, and where federal court has become an increasingly effective (if slow) recourse for well-documented cases with articulable legal error.

Data source: SSA Office of Decision Support and Strategic Information (ODSSI), FY 2025 Waterfall data published January 8, 2026. Data not available for FY 2007–2008, 2010–2011, and 2015. Federal court figures include CDR appeals.