The Social Security Forum

Piemonte’s Perspective

September 25, 2025

George Piemonte, NOSSCR Past President

Proving Limitations: Responding to Supervision

Over the next few issues, I’ll be sharing some of my favorite functional limitations and practical strategies for proving them. Let’s start with an important one: a limited ability to respond appropriately to supervision.


Why This Matters

An inability to accept supervision can stem from physical or mental impairments. Conditions like chronic pain or depression often lead to irritability, making workplace interactions difficult. According to SSR 85-15, the basic mental demands of competitive, unskilled work include the ability—on a sustained basis—“to respond appropriately to supervision, coworkers, and usual work situations.” Similarly, POMS DI 25020.010(B)(2)(c) lists “the ability to accept instructions and respond appropriately to criticism from supervisors” as essential for any job.


What Employers Will Not Tolerate

Some behaviors are deal-breakers, even if they happen only once. Examples include:

  • Verbally abusing or cursing at a supervisor
  • Physical aggression
  • Walking away during instruction or criticism
  • Emotional outbursts such as crying or saying, “I can’t deal with this right now.”

These reactions typically make sustained employment impossible.


How to Prove It

Building a strong case requires evidence from multiple sources:

  • Claimant Testimony: Get detailed descriptions of how the claimant reacts to stress or criticism. Specific examples are powerful.
  • Medical Source Statements: Ask doctors or therapists to document limitations in handling supervision.
  • Lay Witness Statements: Family, friends, and former coworkers can provide real-world observations of angry outbursts, crying spells, or avoidance behaviors.

Final Thoughts

Proving an inability to respond appropriately to supervision can be a compelling way to establish disability. Use every tool available to paint a clear picture of what supervision looks like for your claimant—and why it prevents them from maintaining employment. Creativity and thoroughness make all the difference.


The views and opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of NOSSCR, its leadership, or staff.