The Social Security Forum

Circuit Court Considerations: VE Conflicts and SSR 00-4p

November 20, 2025

Adriana de la Torre, NOSSCR Sustaining Member

VE Conflicts and SSR 00-4p: Ninth Circuit Weighs In

We have a notable remand out of the Ninth Circuit that’s especially relevant for anyone handling cases decided before January 6, 2025. The cutoff date for the transition from SSR 00-4p to SSR 24-3p.

This case is a clean example of what many of us have been arguing for years: Reasoning Level conflicts are real, and ALJs still have a duty to acknowledge and resolve them when raised.

Case Background

The claimant, Boyd, filed for disability benefits due in part to rheumatoid arthritis, a torn rotator cuff, and depression. The ALJ assessed an RFC limiting her to “simple, routine tasks.”

At hearing, the vocational expert (VE) identified three jobs—each classified at DOT Reasoning Level 2. As most of us know, Reasoning Level 2 requires the ability to:

“Apply commonsense understanding to carry out detailed but uninvolved written or oral instructions.”

However, on cross-examination, the VE explicitly acknowledged that an individual limited to simple, routine tasks could not perform work requiring the ability to follow detailed written or oral instructions.

That is an apparent conflict under SSR 00-4p.

The ALJ’s Error

Rather than resolving that conflict, as required, the ALJ dismissed it, relying on Emergency Message 21065, an internal SSA directive stating that reasoning levels should not be considered in assessing vocational conflicts.

The Ninth Circuit was not persuaded.

The court emphasized that because SSR 00-4p was still controlling at the time of Boyd’s decision, the ALJ remained obligated to identify and resolve any conflict between VE testimony and the DOT.

Failure to do so required remand.

Why This Case Matters

This decision reinforces what many of us have continued to argue, even while some adjudicators relied on EM 21065:

✅ Reasoning Level conflicts are “apparent conflicts”
✅ SSR 00-4p required ALJs to ask, and resolve, those conflicts
✅ VE testimony cannot override the DOT without a sufficient explanation

And importantly:

Cases decided prior to January 6, 2025, remain governed by SSR 00-4p, not SSR 24-3p.

So for any claims currently pending at Appeals Council or in federal court where the decision predates January 2025, keep raising these issues. This case strengthens the argument.

Practice Takeaway

When a VE identifies Level 2 (or Level 3) jobs for claimants limited to simple, routine, or one- to two-step tasks, always:

  1. Cross-examine the VE on the “detailed” instructions requirement.
  2. Make the SSR 00-4p objection clearly on the record.
  3. Argue the conflict in post-hearing briefs and at AC/federal review.

This is not hairsplitting. This is ensuring vocational evidence actually matches the RFC.

Precision in vocational evidence is not nitpicking, it’s competent advocacy.

Got any questions? Schedule a consultation with us. I’m here to help. It’s a lot to take in, but we’ll get through it together. After all, navigating these waters is always easier when you’ve got someone to chat with.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of NOSSCR, its leadership, or staff.